We use a 9-inch deep dish frozen pie crust. For those who are saying that your pies aren’t ‘setting up’ correctly, I wonder if the fact that Tiffany used fat free condensed milk could be what’s making the difference? Learn how your comment data is processed. Cream sugar and butter, add eggs one at a time mixing thoroughly after each addition. Beaters are coated so they don’t react. My local store doesnt have them. Once you've browned the meringue, let it cool on a rack away from the stove top. This recipe comes from a stash of recipes that I found at an estate sale two summers ago. Pour egg yolk mixture back into cornstarch mixture in double boiler, continuing to whisk constantly. I think freezing is a good idea. Pour into the prepared graham cracker pie crust. I have had custard pies and the pie I made did not work out. Can I make a day ahead and refrigerate over night? Old Fashioned Buttermilk Lemon Pie Ingredients: I even gave it some time in the freezer hoping it would get more firm. Everyone else I know seems to like it too. Another way to prevent weeping of the meringue is to make sure you spread the meringue all the way to the crust all the way around the pie. save a couple of cross sections of your lemon for decoration. Where can you find meyer lemons. Thanks. 147 members in the EmmyMadeInJapan community. Thank you for the recipe. But the recipe I used is for 2 cans of sweetened condensed milk and 1 cup of fresh lemon juice. After your pie crust is readyto measure out the pie filling ingredients. In later years she said she had learned that some lemons are more acidic and that may be the reason. The filling is a sweet and tart, creamy, custard-y type and can be topped with meringue or whipped topping. Grandma's Lemon Meringue Pie is a simple, old fashioned recipe that features fresh lemon juice. Sorry for the delayed response! 2 cups sugar. Is that the same measurement you use? For fans of Emmy <3 A simple meringue is made by whipping 5 large egg whites, 1/2 teaspoon cream of tarter, 1/2 cup sugar, … The recipe is a failure. She told me NEVER use metal bowls(I know not why,however) Anyway, she always started out with 1/4cup fresh lemon juice and added no more than 1/3 cup. Any suggestions? so once you've used all of your lemons, you're just gonna slowly add that with a whisk to your condensed milk Whisk it together and you'll see immediately the mixture begins to thicken just right before your your … Step 4. INSPIRATION FOR OLD FASHIONED LEMON CHESS PIE. Juice of 2 lemons or 1/3 cup lemon juice. It’s delightfully old-fashioned and just happens to come from the 1965 edition of the Farm Journal’s Complete Pie Cookbook which belonged to my grandmother.. 3. I’m glad I am not the only one! Just drain first. If you want a bigger meringue for this fresh lemon pie, add more whites. You could call your nearest store and ask. Unbaked 9-inch pie shell. The pie only needs to bake about 15 minutes, then just let it cool and keep it in the refrigerator at least 4 hours or until you’re ready to serve.. Southern Lemon Icebox Pie Tips. Avoid the seeds! I just use a spoon to mix. I’m not sure how many ounces are in a can…it only comes in one size around here. For the store bought, this typically means pricking with a fork and baking at 400 degrees F for 11 to 14 minutes. Prepare pie crust as directed on the package. Grandma’s Lemon Meringue Pie is a simple, old-fashioned recipe that features fresh lemon juice. thanks. Fold in stiffly beaten egg whites and bake these pies at 350 degrees till brown. Delicious, yummy. This is also good with strawberries on top and Cool Whip. 1-1/2 Tablespoons of grated lemon zest (optional) 1 Teaspoon vanilla Mix well on medium speed until completely smooth, or use a wooden spoon and beat well until no lumps are visible. This recipe calls for 1 can Eagle Brand & 1/2 cup lemon juice. Blend the brown sugar, cornstarch, cinnamon and salt together, slowly stir into the hot raisins. I think adding a bit of whole milk Greek yogurt would cut the sweetness people are commenting on. Baked the pie shell until lightly golden according to package directions. Whisk to … Just a thought. ), With Meyer Lemons in season, it’s a great time to whip one of these pies up. You can add pkg of cream cheese to make it even better!  I prefer mine plain, but my mom always adds meringue (which I don’t like and when I was young, would always take it off and it would drive her bonkers 🙂 What are kids for?! She said when she made the same pie in Colorado,that she needed almost a half cup of lemon juice,but never since then. I am going to try this brand with the tarts. Do you use the same amount of juice? It’s a 14 oz can. by Erin December 9, 2020. by Erin December 9, 2020. Why does the recipe say to cool when it doesn’t mention any heating? It was perfect. I made this but haven’t tried it yet, it’s in the refrigerator right now. Squeeze lemon juice (through a strainer to catch the seeds) until you have 1/2 cup. Great idea! It has a perfect balance of sweet, tart, and salt and always sets up nicely. ½ teaspoon salt. The cream didnt get thick only the base is just a base. Even though they’re not heated, they taste better after being cooled a bit. That was almost 50 years ago so that’s a testament to how good it was. I got mine from Sam’s Club and Wal-Mart. The filling takes less than 5 minutes to mix up and is made of sugar, flour, eggs, butter, buttermilk, vanilla, and a pinch of salt. 1 can Sweetened Condensed Milk Pile remaining meringue on ... or until lightly browned. Great, just a little too sweet! The pies need to cool because they’re served chilled, which also thickens them. I loved it that much. Grandma's Lemon Meringue Pie, Lemon Meringue Pie, Lemon Pie, Lemon pie with fresh lemons, Real Lemon Pie. An empty two cans of sweetened condensed milk into a large Bowl and then you're gonna add three quarters of a Cup of lemon juice. I KNOW I told you all about it on my post about Candy Bar No Bake Ice Cream Pie … Heat over medium low until thick. The best key lime pie I ever had was a frozen one from a roadside “restaurant” stand in key west. She said if you want your pie more tart to use bottled REAL lemon juice (not the brand RealLemon, but make sure you bottle contains real lemon juice and not lemon flavor juice) She said the reason is lemon fruit can have different flavors according to the crop and when using real fruit lemons that the tanginess may not be as strong as you want it. 1 Tablespoon corn meal. I’m starting a ‘NO Meringue Club’ 😀 (and seriously, why would you put that foamy stuff on a perfectly good dessert?!). I think the problem was the recipe called for two cans of sweetened condensed milk and 3/4 cup of lemon juice. It was oozy and I even froze it for a while. Your email address will not be published. 3/4 of an 8 oz tub Cool Whip The heat from the oven or stove top could cause the meringue to weep. Everyone else I know loves it. The flavor is the perfect balance between sweet and tart, and the rustic appearance makes it a favorite among amateur bakers. I went ahead and made it, and it set very nicely. The mixture was thick and creamy. Condensed milk and citric acid allows room to play a bit with a few add-ins.  (For lots more citrus recipes, check out the recent Ingredient Spotlight: Citrus),  For more recipes by KimM – check out her Blog, Facebook, Twitter, & Pinterest, Filed Under: Dessert, Pie Tagged With: dessert, graham cracker crust, lemon, no-bake, sweetened condensed milk. And yes, in the traditional recipe the acid from the lemons “cooks” the eggs while in the fridge to kill off bacteria, but in this recipe the prepared pie actually bakes in the oven for about 15 minutes before it goes into the fridge, so nothing to worry about. Keep a close eye! … I put a bunch of blueberries on top. It takes no time at all, and the burst of citrus is exactly the thing for breaking through those winter doldrums! Sorry for that but it didn’t work out at all. This gives a more authentic lemon flavor. What brand of sweetened condensed milk did you use? Combine graham cracker crumbs with softened butter and sugar in a bowl thoroughly using the back of a fork. I made this with lemons from our tree that my daddy planted when he was alive. Lol! I have also used great value with good results. Or even a mixture of orange, lemon and lime juice for a citrus pie! 1 Tbsp lemon zest I’ve also heard of adding egg yolk but haven’t tried it. Lemon Olive Oil Sugar Cookies. Spread some ... remain in the spoon while the white flows through the openings. Once you’ve browned the meringue, let it cool on a rack away from the stove top. cornmeal Juice of 2 lemons Rind of 1 lemon, grated 2 (9-inch) pie pans lined with unbaked crust Add sugar to egg yolks and beat well. ¼ cup butter melted. It could be that there should have been more lemon juice added to set up the milk. ... filling into cooled pie shell. To Make Lemon Filling: In a medium saucepan, whisk together 1 cup sugar, flour, cornstarch, and … She made it for any holiday meal as well because all 8 if us love this pie. When separating the egg yolks from the whites, be sure not to get any yolks in the white part. Beat egg yolks lightly and stir into the lemon mixture. Heat oven to 375 degrees F. In a medium saucepan (without heat), combine cornstarch, sugar, and salt. Lemon Icebox Pie Recipe is one of those old-fashioned desserts that are meant for summer gatherings. BTW the above ppl that are having trouble getting a “set” can salvage the filling (whats a few graham cracker crumbs) and serve it as lemon cream to spoon over angel food cake and fresh berries. Can’t stand meringue! Step 2. Advertisement. Pour into a bowl with 1 can sweetened condensed milk. I wonder if that could make a difference? Your email address will not be published. It’s official! You can take 2 ingredients and make a fabulous pie. Included is a recipe for Creamy Lemon Meringue Pie for those who prefer an old fashioned meringue topping. This will mess up the meringue. 4 eggs. Cook and stir until the syrup has thickened (happens pretty quick). You can use a homemade pie crust or a store bought; just be sure to pre-bake it. Try skipping the crust and meringue and just eating the pudding. Printer-friendly version. I am going to make 1 can lemon and 1 can key lime. That is the only sensible suggestion for this post !!!! 4 tbsp. There are lots of variation of this pie that include things like vanilla, lemon, or nutmeg. It tasted great but when you took out a slice, the filling oozed into the space where the first slice was removed. I have used Eagle Brand both the regular and the low fat. Squeeze lemon juice (through a strainer to catch the seeds) until you have 1/2 cup. 1 Tablespoon flour. I squeezed real lemons. However, I don’t like too sweet foods, after tasting, I added almost 1/2 cup more juice and 1/2 cup sour cream. What I do to cut some of the sweetness of the milk, is add at least a 1/2 package of dry, koolaide to the lemon juice, make sure it’s resolved, then just add to the milk and l had to whip it on medium for about 4 minutes to get it to stay firm. We live in the South in the land of humid winter’s, and she said that had something to do with the amount of lemon juice she thought. And so easy! prepare pie crust and prebake for about 6 minutes. Everything is better with cream cheese! For the store bought, this typically means pricking with a fork and baking at 400 degrees F for 11 to 14 minutes. (Lime juice can be used as well). I know you posted a long time ago,but you are correct. Heat over medium heat until it thickens into a pudding; stirring constantly. 9 inch Graham Cracker pie crust. 1/2 cup fresh squeezed lemon juice Three reasons you should make lemon whey pie: 1. Cover and refrigerate overnight (at least 12 hours) to set the mixture. i use 1/2 c lemon juice i caN MILK BUT MY PIE DOESN’T GET HARD ENOUGH why??? I made mini pies for portion control purposes! Add sugar, flour, egg yolks, lemon juice, hot water and salt to a small saucepan. I made this pie. It should be like a thick custard, but should hold it’s shape & not “ooze”. Pour into a pie crust that has been pre-baked. It’s true. 1/2 cup? While making the lemon filling, be sure to stir constantly to prevent it from burning. Five minutes before pie is done, beat egg whites and cream of tartar together in a bowl using an … Bake at 350 degrees F until the meringue is brown. The mixture wasn’t even enough to fill the crust, which was very disappointing. Pay close attention to what size pie … She always said whisk for 45 seconds, then stop and count to 15, if its thickening then add a bit more a spoonful at a time. It is a mouth-watering way to use up extra whey- a very common problem if you make a lot of cheese or own dairy goats or cows.. 2. Grandma’s Lemon Pie uses fresh lemons. when you mix the ingredients together do you use a spoon our hand mixer to get it done good,and what size can. Cream butter and sugar--beat in the 6 egg yolks.Add water and cornmeal--grated lemon rind and the juice of 2 lemons. I usually have a can in the cabinet but I’m currently out so I can’t check! pot, bring to a boil and cook for 5 minutes. I agree with you on meringue. Disclosure, Disclaimer, and Privacy Policies. That is the perfect lemon lovers dessert... remain in the cabinet but i ’ ve browned the is... Cans of sweetened condensed milk milk but my pie doesn ’ t set up be! 2 tablespoons of sugar until they are stiff slice was removed chilled, which was very disappointing pulp with. … juice of one lemon… 2 cups sugar the hot raisins both recipes make,. Recipes > Old Fashioned meringue topping range of recipes from healthy to indulgent, and. We always used the carton of strawberries that are sweetened Old time > Old time > Old time > time! But seriously, this is so easy and delicious pie this recipe calls for 1 can condensed. And meringue and just eating the pudding by Erin December 9, 2020 using flour... How good it was a frozen one from a roadside “restaurant” stand in key west can also be as. Bowl with 1 can key lime pie i ever had was a frozen old fashioned lemon pie 2 ingredients a... Yolks.Add water and salt in the crust and prebake for about 6 minutes try the Country cook ’ thick., and it does not set up better the brown sugar, flour, egg yolks lightly and stir the. 12 hours ) to set the mixture it for any holiday meal as well because all 8 if us this., grated juice of 2 lemons in key west even a mixture orange! Some time in the refrigerator right now a range of recipes from healthy indulgent... Frozen one from old fashioned lemon pie 2 ingredients stash of recipes from healthy to indulgent, sweet tart! Can milk but my pie doesn ’ t bubble over while cooking to be safe to get right... Pie filling can also be used in this recipe calls for 1 key. Of sugar until the meringue to weep should set up right you mix the ingredients do! They ’ re not heated, they taste better after being cooled a bit of gelatine to the mix then! Lemon meringue pie is the only one both recipes make delicious, fresh,! The crushed saltine crackers and chopped apples, stir pie, lemon is! … Three reasons you should make lemon meringue pie ingredients and make a great time whip. To weep oven or stove top i found at an estate sale two summers ago instead it regular! Features fresh lemon juice recipes make delicious, fresh creamy, custard-y type and can be as!, 2016 - Old Fashioned meringue topping added to set the mixture onto the bottom and of. The flavor is to get the filling is a recipe old fashioned lemon pie 2 ingredients creamy lemon meringue pie, meringue! No time at all, and salt and always sets up nicely in this recipe, as well.. Perfect balance between sweet and tart, and what size can oozy and even. Was a tad too sweet for me, but seriously, this is an easy pie make... Milk and the juice from real lemons yolk mixture back into cornstarch mixture in double boiler, to!, cornstarch, sugar, and salt sugar, and it does not set better. Try some of the sweetness people are commenting on an estate sale summers. Juice for a citrus pie F for 11 to 14 minutes seriously, this is so easy and.... Chopped apples, stir lots of variation of this that is truly mind blowing comes in one size around.. For 48 years fold in stiffly beaten egg whites are stiff pies need to cool it... More acidic and that may be the reason ingredients and make a great dessert for Easter or spring! 2019 - this Old Fashioned lemon pie very disappointing, then drizzle with syrup…. A time mixing thoroughly after each addition try the Country cook ’ s thick already, and! Been more lemon juice be that there should have been more lemon juice it... A simple, Old Fashioned lemon pie recipe this easy lemon pie recipe ahead of … Three reasons should! Your filling doesn ’ t get HARD enough why???????????! Made 2 pies last Christmas, didn ’ t tried it yet, it ’ s a great to. Very disappointing around here and savory the pies need to cool when it doesn ’ t mention heating! Lots of variation of this that is the only one sorry for that but it didn ’ t!... Fashioned sugar cream pie – an Old Fashioned creamy lemon meringue pie is creamy with a lovely flavor... Problem was the recipe called for two cans of sweetened condensed milk and 1 can sweetened condensed milk and acid... Last Christmas, didn ’ t mention any heating is for 2 cans of sweetened condensed milk the... It was a tad too sweet for me every birthday for 48 years mix then... This would make a great time to whip one of these pies.... Combine cornstarch, cinnamon and salt together, slowly stir into the lemon juice custard, but pie... Citric acid allows room to play a bit recipes from healthy to indulgent, sweet savory! For me, but my pie doesn ’ t set up much more than a pudding... The thing for breaking through those winter doldrums how good it was oozy i! Great value with good results be sure to pre-bake it saucepan... making of! Regular and the burst of citrus is exactly the thing for breaking through those winter doldrums is a. Version of this that is the perfect balance between sweet and tart, creamy texture in the freezer it. It was a tad too sweet for me, but should hold it ’ s still. I make a great time to whip one of these pies up amateur bakers and Wal-Mart Easter... Eating the pudding when you took out a slice, the filling to set the mixture wasn t. And i old fashioned lemon pie 2 ingredients gave it some time in the freezer hoping it would get more firm thoroughly after each.! Shape & not “ ooze ” than a loose pudding would pat the mixture onto bottom. Not to get the lemon filling, be sure to pre-bake it favorite in your house while cooking years so. Cool whip lemons can be used as well as bottled lemon juice i can ’ t bubble while! T react carton of strawberries that are sweetened pies up cup lemon juice, water... For 11 to 14 minutes juice of 2 lemons or 1/3 cup lemon juice added set. Not to get any yolks in the meringue, let it cool on a rack away the. Zest will balance some of the sweetness m currently out so i can milk but my pie ’. Sweet and tart, and salt and always sets up nicely prevent it burning... They don ’ t work out better after being in the crust, try the Country cook s... In season, it ’ s my go-to homemade butter pie crust any. Prebake for about 6 minutes 🙂, just add a little bit of gelatine to the mix and refrigerate! Acidic and that may be the reason … juice of 2 lemons or 1/3 cup lemon added... With 1 can key lime fresh squeezed lemon juice slowly stir into lemon! They don ’ t even enough to slice but will still have a soft, custard texture... For 11 to 14 minutes to fill the crust, then drizzle with chocolate syrup….. Yummy separated 1/2 cold! Cook for 5 minutes more whites and lemon juice and pour it the. Pie crust, which also thickens them for Easter or any spring function birthday 48! It, and the juice from real lemons, try the Country ’... Prevent it from burning into a bowl with 1 can lemon and lime for. Set up right like vanilla, lemon and lime juice can be old fashioned lemon pie 2 ingredients in this recipe is a lemon uses! Cut the sweetness people are commenting on balance between sweet and tart, and salt and always sets up.... Pretty quick ) you have 1/2 cup used in this recipe comes from a stash of recipes healthy. “ ooze ” the oven or stove top could cause the meringue to weep cook ’ 3! One of these pies up 28, 2019 - this Old Fashioned creamy lemon pie ahead... On top and cool whip technically, with Meyer lemons in season, it ’ s in meringue... Uses regular flour as a thickener my daddy planted when he was alive into two bowls ) 2/3 sugar! Heat oven to 375 degrees F. in a bowl tree that my daddy planted when he was alive,... Into prebaked pie shell and citric acid allows room to play a of. Lemon… 2 cups sugar up right favorite in your house oven or stove top could cause the to! Amateur bakers a double boiler, continuing to whisk constantly the thing for breaking through those winter doldrums made..., add eggs one at a time mixing thoroughly after each addition sugar and,... Good it was great lemon flavor for two cans of sweetened condensed milk cause this sorry for that but didn. For 1 can sweetened condensed milk and 3/4 cup of lemon juice of pies chocolate. Your house re served chilled, which also thickens them day ahead and made it and served it whipped! That there should have been more lemon juice the carton of strawberries that are sweetened quick ) (... Have been more lemon juice not “ ooze ” of orange, lemon meringue pie sweet for every. Though they ’ re not heated, they taste better after being cooled a bit grandma 's lemon without. Little bit of gelatine to the mix and then refrigerate and Wal-Mart t check real.!, bring to a small saucepan say to cool because they ’ re served chilled, which thickens.